California picks a new insurance commissioner on Tuesday, November 3.
Your next loss is governed by the policy you hold, not the platform that wins.
The November 3 vote
California elects a new insurance commissioner on November 3, 2026.
Two names are on the ballot: Ben Allen, California State Senator, and Jane Kim, Attorney/Consumer Advocate. Those are their ballot designations on the Secretary of State's certified list. No incumbent is running. On November 3, polls are open from 7:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. A mailed ballot must be postmarked on or before November 3.
Both candidates describe the same market failure. Allen's campaign says insurers "are pulling out of communities and leaving homeowners stranded on the overburdened FAIR Plan." Kim's says insurers "raise our rates, cancel our policies, and delay, deny, and underpay valid claims."
State Farm stopped accepting new California homeowners applications in 2023. On September 18, 2026, the Department of Insurance said State Farm had filed to resume, for homes that meet IBHS Wildfire Prepared Home standards. The Department also said State Farm was "not open for new business yet."
Two platforms
Allen, in his campaign's words:
- Modernize rate-setting with "wildfire catastrophe modeling and the inclusion of reinsurance costs in rate applications."
- Make rate decisions "within months, not years."
- Expand community hardening "to help residents lower risk—and therefore lower premiums."
Kim, in her campaign's words:
- "One public, non-profit program that covers wildfire for every home in the state," with participation "mandatory."
- Fix the FAIR Plan.
- "Freeze your coverage when you file a claim" and "penalize delays to speed up payments."
These are each campaign's own statements. They aren't Sovra's assessment of what either candidate could get done.
What already changed
Whoever wins inherits a different rulebook than the one in place in July.
In September the Governor signed the Disaster Recovery Reform Act (SB 876). It doubles penalties during declared emergencies for claims-settlement violations. It also requires insurers to offer extended replacement cost and additional living expense coverage when a policy is written. It phases in from January 1, 2027.
The Governor also signed the Smoke Damage Recovery Act (AB 1795), which sets standards for testing and restoring smoke-damaged homes, and the Make It FAIR Act (AB 1680), which tightens oversight of the FAIR Plan.
On rate review, the Department finalized a voluntary, public "comprehensiveness review" step that comes before a formal Proposition 103 filing. It also put new intervenor rules into effect.
Where the platforms stop
Proposition 103 rate approval does not apply to surplus lines. The Department says it plainly: "Non-admitted insurers are not subject to prior approval of rates."
For a household whose home is already on a surplus lines or manuscript form, a faster rate review isn't the lever that decides its next claim. The contract is.
Our reading
Our reading: the operative contract governs the loss. Not the contract you were quoted years ago, and not the contract either candidate is campaigning on. New consumer-protection statutes add pathways; none of them replace advocacy at the moment of loss.
Before you renew
Three questions for your broker before you renew.
- Is my home policy admitted or surplus lines?
- When does it renew, and what changed in the form?
- Does it carry extended replacement cost and enough additional living expense?
Neither Sovra Capital nor Soteria Collective endorses candidates.
Soteria Collective is our private risk advisory partner. They offer a second look at insurance for high-net-worth and ultra-high-net-worth families, reviewing the practical questions against the policies and changes you share.
soteriacollective.co (opens Soteria Collective's site)
Coverage depends on the issued policy and the facts of the loss. Nothing here is legal or tax advice.
Sources: California Secretary of State, Certified List of Candidates for the November 3, 2026, General Election (Aug 27, 2026) and General Election page (sos.ca.gov). California Department of Insurance press releases and consumer alerts, Aug 11 – Oct 19, 2026, and Purchasing Group guidance (insurance.ca.gov). State Farm newsroom, May 2023. Candidate positions are quoted from benallenca.com and janekim.org, as each campaign states them. Adapted from Soteria Collective's Viewpoint "The California Commissioner Race," July 2026.